The Super Bowl is Here! - Final Results
Thursday, January 29th, 2009The Savants are owning the playoffs - up a combined $150 going into the Super Bowl. The likelihood of that continuing is pretty low given Dick and Rand have taken opposite sides of the game. As a special treat, all of our season-long Guest Prognosticators were invited to make a pick for the game. Plus 130 for the Playoffs, not bad, but just wait until next season.
Special Note #1: Cassidy remains hopeful that the Cowboys will actually be the team that is introduced to take the field against the Steelers on Sunday. Of course, that presumes that they are a team versus a bunch of over-hyped, over-paid, under-performing individuals who happen to show up (not necessarily on time) at the same place on Sundays.
Special Note #2: There are 2 principles alive during the playoffs: 1 - Believe in Big Ben, and 2 - Never, Ever Bet Against Kurt Warner in the Playoffs. Which Principle will win out - we’ll see on Sunday.
Super Bowl Sunday
Dick +50 + 50 = +100
Tom +70 - 20 = +50
Rand +30 -50 = -20
Guest Pickers (combined) -70 +50 = -20
This week’s picks
Dick: $50 on Arizona +7, Dick stays on the Arizona bandwagon. Is it because he doesn’t want the Steelers to pass the Cows in Super Bowl wins? He says that it not it. It must be that he knows: Never, Ever Bet against Kurt Warner in the Playoffs. +++ Cassidy falls the simple rule - Never, Ever Bet against Kurt Warner in the Playoffs - and it pays off with a Win for the Playoffs on top of his Regular Season Win. Congratulations on taking the other Savants down this season.
Tom: $10 on Pitts/AZ Under 46.5. What to do when your guiding principles collide - PUNT. Since I believe in Big Ben, and I know better than betting against Kurt Warner, here are a series of $10 picks. XXX What happened in that 4th Quarter.
$10 on Arizona +.5 in the 1st Qtr. I am hoping for a slow 0-0 start in the first quarter. XXX Ooops, hard to out score Pitts when you brilliantly elect to kick off and then run a total of 3 plays in the quarter.
$10 on Pittsburgh -3 in the 2nd Qtr. Why does this quarter have the biggest spread? Since I don’t know, it is obvious that you need to be making a pick on this quarter. +++ Lucky - of course not, who didn’t know that the Steelers would run back a 100-yard interception with no time remaining on the clock.
$10 on Pittsburgh Under 27. If Pittsburgh’s defense can control the Cardinals, they’ll sit on the ball (intentional or not is an unimportant detail). Push - they didn’t want to score this many points, unfortunately Arizona remembered that Larry Fitzgerald was on their team in the 2nd half.
$10 on 4th Qtr Under 13. No thought process involved on this one other than I think the game is an under. XXX missed that by a bunch - 23 points in the quarter after 27 in the first 3 quarters.
Rand: $50 on Pittsburgh -7. Rand jumps on the Steeler Bandwagon as they beat the Titan-nemisis Ravens to get to the big game. Is Arizona the luckiest team to make it to the Super Bowl - let’s review their road to the big game: Atlanta one year removed from a horrible season sporting a rookie QB and Coach, Carolina with the single worst quarterback performance in playoff history, and Philly with Donavan electing not to make any plays in the first half of the game? Surely Big Ben’s bunch can trounce these guys, right? XXXX Believe in Big Ben remains in effect for the game score, but Never, Ever Bet Against Kurt Warner in the Playoffs carries the day against the line.
Our Super Bowl Guest Prognosticators are listed below - headlining the group is none other than John Beckert. John was plus 50 in his week as the GP. John is a noted Steeler fan who again gets rewarded with a team that is enjoyable to follow, and that does things the right way. What fun is that? How about a following a team that is a walking talking soap opera - so much so that they’ll actually have 2 reality TV shows airing this year. Will John surprise us by picking against the Steelers? Of course not, but he does shy away from the end of game total.
John: $50 on Pittsburgh -.5 in the 3rd Qtr. Is John basing the pick on the Steelers overwhelming 3rd quarter domination this season, or is he avoiding the end of game total thinking it could be a close game. Stay tuned - perhaps he’ll disclose the thought process after the game. ++++ Super Pick. John gets the pick right by going with the 3rd quarter, but not the end of the game score. John nails both his regular season and playoff pick as a Guest Picker. He may be a little too good at this for us.
Our Season-Long Guest Prognosticators:
The Arizona Bandwagon: Interestingly enough, not a single GP picked Pittsburgh -7 in this game. Apparently they don’t know what Rand knows - or vice versa. Dave Largent, Joe Grant, Mark Nordman, Mike Kinman and Bill Henslee all are taking the Cardinals +7. Nordman goes so far as to predict the outright Arizona win. Dave, Joe and Mark all put the load on the Cardinals with Bill allocating 20 of his war chest to the pick. Add to this list the picks of Monty Becton, Jeff Porter,and Steve Ranneywhose picks below indicate they favor the Cardinals, you have a vast majority of the GPs on the Cardinal Bandwagon. Bill Henslee’s remaining picks fall into this category, so they are listed here: $20 on Pitts Under 27 and $10 on AZ Over 20. Mike Kinman adds that he picks the Cardinals and all the overs on the Prop bets. ++++ The group of Dave Largent, Joe Grant, Mark Nordman, Mike Kinman and Bill Henslee nail all of their bets on Arizona.
The Cassidy Factor: We did have an unusual prediction, Larry Cassidy predicted a push. With the sort of Cassidy precision we know and love, who needs to take one side or the other when you know it is going to be a push. Larry’s Final Score Prediction: Pitts 24 - AZ 17. I suppose that means he’s taking the under. Hmmmm, right on the outcome, but the push on the final score doesn’t happen.
The Rational Approach (aka closest to my approach): Steve Robinson puts $30 on the 2nd Qtr going Over 13, and $20 on Pittsburgh -.5 in the 3rd quarter (joining John Beckert with this one). +++ Steve nails both picks here. Just showing off I suppose.
The folks who want to show off: We have 5 GP’s elect to make a prediction on all the various prop bets. There picks are listed below with initials for each picker: Scott Holtzman (SH), Monty Becton (MB), Steve Ranney (SR), Lynn Conto (LC) and Jeff Porter (JP).
Prop Bets: SH MB SR LC JP
1st Half/Pitts -4 C C C P C - Pitts covers, only SR gets this one - 1 for 5.
1st Half/O/U 23.5 U U U U U - Last play TD takes half Over - 0 for 5.
2nd Half/Pitts -3 P C C P C - Pitts covers - SH and SR correct. 2 for 5.
2nd Half/O/U 23.5 O U O O O - 4th Quarter flurry of scoring. 4 for 5.
1st QTR/ Pitts -.5 C P C C C - Pitts covers. 1 for 5
1st QTR/O/U 10 U O U O O - Under. 2 for 5
2nd QTR/Pitts -3 P C C P C - Pitts covers. 2 for 5
2nd QTR/O/U 13.5 O O U U O - Over. 3 for 5
3rd QTR/Pitts -.5 P C C P C - Pitts covers. 2 for 5
3rd QTR/O/U 10 O O O O O - Under. Ouch. 0 for 5
4th QTR/Pitts -.5 P C C C C - Cardinals cover. Wow - 4 for 5
4th QTR/O/U 13 O O O O O - Over. Double Wow - 5 for 5
Pitts O/U 27 O U U O U Under. 3 for 5
AZ O/U 20 U O O U O Over. 3 for 5.
Scott Holtzman leads the group with a 7-7 finish on the prop bets. Monty Becton, Stever Ranney, Lynn Conto and Jeff Porter all notch 6-8 records. The back and forth nature of the game caused the Cardinals supporters to end up under .500 even though their team covered for the game.
Thank you for your support and participation during the season. What’s next for the Sports Savants. Stay tuned.
Note: The Sports Savants do not gamble with real money and do not endorse, recommend or promote doing so. The dollar figures above are in “pretend” money, as a way of measuring our success in the game. Not only is gambling illegal in many jurisdictions, it is also pretty dumb. In the end, the house always wins. That’s why the house has gold plated ceilings, dancing girls, magic shows and enormous fountains out front.


